The Lincoln Plawg - the blog with footnotes
Sunday, January 02, 2005
Those faulty historical analogies again
There was a time in the run-up to the Iraq invasion when the War Party was pretty hot on the Munich/Chamberlain/Churchill variety of bollocks.
I wrote as long ago as September 14 2002 linking, amongst other things, an interesting piece Munich: Reassessing the Diplomatic Value of Appeasement which tries to separate fact from self-serving fantasy.
I chance to find another piece (PDF) along the same lines: Perils of Reasoning by Historical Analogy: Munich, Vietnam, and American Use of Force Since 1945 by Jeffrey Record, then prof at the Air Force University.
I have no immediate use for this. Those Iranian nuclear facilities, though, must be causing Osiraq-yearning itchiness of the trigger-fingers of Likudniks and PNAC-ers in and around the (for what of a better word) administration...
free website counter